• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Submissions
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Aug 9, 2022
  • Startup
    • Creating a Plan
    • Funding a Startup
    • Franchise Center
    • Getting Your Office Ready
    • Making Your Business Official
    • Marketing Your New Business
    • Personal Readiness
  • Run & Grow
    • Customer Service
    • Human Resources
    • Innovation
    • Legal
    • Operations
    • Risk Management
  • Leadership
    • Best Practices
    • Communication
    • Green Initiatives
    • Open Culture
    • Strategic Planning
    • People Skills
  • Sales & Marketing
    • Advertising and Lead Generation
    • Marketing Innovations
    • Marketing Plans
    • Online Marketing
    • Relationships
    • Sales Activities
  • Finance
    • Budgeting and Personal Finance
    • Payments and Collections
    • Tax and Accounting
    • Pricing Strategy
    • Working with Investors
    • Working with Lenders
  • Tech
    • eCommerce
    • Hardware
    • Software
    • Security
    • Tech Reviews
    • Telecom
  • Shop

SmallBizClub

Helping You Succeed

Home / Leadership / Open Culture / How Performance Reviews Can Kill Organizational Culture
How Performance Reviews Can Kill Organizational Culture

How Performance Reviews Can Kill Organizational Culture

904 Views

Jan 21, 2020 By Dave Brock

I’m an unabashed fan of Shane Parrish and the Farnam Street Blog. I study everything they publish, listen to every podcast, read every article and book they reference. It is the single smartest site I have ever found, I encourage everyone to visit and learn on a regular basis.

So it was interesting reading a post, “How Performance Reviews Can Kill Your Culture” I found myself both agreeing with, but strongly disagreeing with the discussion in the article.

First, most every organization does a terrible job with the performance review process. We know the litany of complaints, bad implementations, poor communication of expectations, poor or no coaching for performance improvement, poor/misguided review process, and meaningless reporting to keep HR off our backs.

Most performance management systems are broken from day 1 and become less relevant over time.

Somehow, we must make them more relevant, more useful, more fair if we are ever to drive sustained performance improvement, or create workplaces where people thrive, feel valued, contribute, and grow.

But, uncharacteristically, the thinking of performance reviews presented in the article is very simplistic. It basically poses two extremes:

  • The dysfunction of the stack ranking/comparative performance review process.
  • The evaluation of the individual against past performance: “Did they get better?”

Let me address the second first. Without a doubt, we want to create organizational cultures around continuous improvement and learning. We want people who strive to constantly improve and get better.

Part of every performance evaluation should be “have they learned, are they better?” The individual that does not continue to learn, improve, or grow, will not be competitive in the changing markets, needs, or requirements for success in the future.

But the evaluation of “did they get better,” is insufficient. Getting better is meaningless if the person is still underperforming. If the person is not competitive for current and future needs for job success, we do them, our customers, and our organizations a disservice.

I get how the comparative review process can become very dysfunctional, but I think that’s less an issue of the comparative process and more how we manage/implement the process. I’ve seen and been part of many organizations that harness this process very constructively, helping individuals and the organization grow and improve.

Let’s face it, we live in a comparative world! We evaluate alternative vendors, we evaluate alternative employers, we look at competition, other companies/organizations. We evaluate and make comparisons in virtually everything we do. We evaluate our friends, families, co-workers, and just about everything we can.

Sometimes those comparisons are fair, objective, even constructive. Sometimes they are not and there is no attempt for any fairness, objectivity, or constructiveness. We are as guilty of doing these things to others as they are guilty of doing to us.

Many of us, perhaps, most compete with others, trying to improve ourselves, or at least our self-assessment. Again, some of this is healthy/constructive, some is dysfunctional.

But to ignore these comparative processes is to ignore reality—human nature, how organizations, and societies work, how individuals, organizations, and societies grow and improve.

Our goal as managers and leaders shouldn’t be just evaluating, “Are you better today than you were yesterday,” but also harnessing comparative assessments in constructive ways, helping both the individual and organization grow.

Filed Under: Open Culture Tagged With: Culture, Performance Reviews

Source: Partners in Excellence

Dave Brock

Dave Brock

Dave Brock is the founder of Partners in EXCELLENCE, a consulting and services company helping to improve the effectiveness of business professionals with strategy development, organizational planning, and implementation. Dave has spent his career working for and with high performance organizations, ranging from the Fortune 25 to startups, including companies such as IBM, HP, Nokia, AT&T, Microsoft, General Electric, and many, many more. The work Dave does with business strategies is closely tied to personal effectiveness of the people in the organization. As a result, Dave is deeply involved in the development of a number of training and coaching programs.

Related Posts

  • 5 Ways to Overcome Startup Hurdles
  • how-to-make-sure-your-startup-is-built-on-valuesEvery Business Can Make the World a Better Place: Sim Shain’s Mission
  • the-6-a-s-of-successful-leadershipJackie Meyer Wants You to Fall Back in Love with Your Job: How She Inspires Her Tax Team

Primary Sidebar

Random

a-startup-goldmine--combining-healthcare-and-technology

‍9 Tips for Making Your Healthcare Business More Successful

Aug 9, 2022 By Charlotte Sylvester

employment-practices-liability

‍5 Business Liabilities That Can Cause You A Ton Of Trouble

Aug 9, 2022 By Jeremy Bowler

The Ultimate Guide to Starting a Meal Prep Business

Aug 8, 2022 By Emily Newton

6 Best Practices to Optimize Your Google Business Profile

Aug 5, 2022 By SmallBizClub

You Can and Should Skip Entry-level Jobs

Aug 5, 2022 By Ryan Kidman

Footer

About Us

Small Biz Club is the premier destination for small business owners and entrepreneurs. To succeed in business, you have to constantly learn about new things, evaluate what you’re doing, and look for ways to improve—that’s what we’re here to help you do.

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Copyright © 2022 by Tarkenton Institute, Inc. All Rights Reserved | Terms | Privacy