• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Submissions
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Mar 21, 2023
  • Startup
    • Creating a Plan
    • Funding a Startup
    • Franchise Center
    • Getting Your Office Ready
    • Making Your Business Official
    • Marketing Your New Business
    • Personal Readiness
  • Run & Grow
    • Customer Service
    • Human Resources
    • Innovation
    • Legal
    • Operations
    • Risk Management
  • Leadership
    • Best Practices
    • Communication
    • Green Initiatives
    • Open Culture
    • Strategic Planning
    • People Skills
  • Sales & Marketing
    • Advertising and Lead Generation
    • Marketing Innovations
    • Marketing Plans
    • Online Marketing
    • Relationships
    • Sales Activities
  • Finance
    • Budgeting and Personal Finance
    • Payments and Collections
    • Tax and Accounting
    • Pricing Strategy
    • Working with Investors
    • Working with Lenders
  • Tech
    • eCommerce
    • Hardware
    • Software
    • Security
    • Tech Reviews
    • Telecom
  • Shop

SmallBizClub

Helping You Succeed

taxbandits banner
Home / Run and Grow / Legal / Is This Partner Arrangement Fair?
Is This Partner Arrangement Fair?

Is This Partner Arrangement Fair?

2108 Views

Nov 5, 2013 By Tim Berry

I get these emails, summarizing one side of an argument, asking me to guess or comment on fairness. For example, in an email I just received, the one asking me has worked for 18 months “with significant intellectual contribution.” He’s apparently resenting the other partner, who has shelled out $560,000 and wants a guaranteed payback before other partners get it, and ends up with 65% ownership. The question:

 
Isn’t that excessive? 
 
I can’t even start to answer that without asking questions first: 
 
  1. Was there no agreement before you started those 18 months working? Really? Or are you wanting to change what you agreed? 
  2. Did you put in no money? If not, did you work for ownership, without being paid? And if you didn’t work for free, then why doesn’t the partner who put in all the money and paid your salary own it completely? Why only 65%? How can that be excessive? 
 
My advice is to get professional help. Ideally you find somebody you can both trust, with some professional qualifications and experience, and talk it through. Make sure that person understands business, business law, and small business. 
 
There are people who have licenses and professional qualifications to call themselves mediators. Pay somebody to help you solve this. 
 
What I particularly hate in this context is when people spend the time and do the work and develop the business without spelling these things out, and then, when it’s way too late, discover that they had radically different ideas about who owns what. 
 
Way too often, you can add up the percent of ownership in the heads of the partners and discover between them they think they own like 200% of the company. That’s because one thinks the idea was worth 50% or more of the ownership, the other thinks the day-to-day work was worth 50% or more of the ownership, and another thinks having written checks and invested was worth 50% or more of the ownership.
 
My first instinct is to go with the money. The one who put in all the money deserves all the ownership. That’s simple enough. 
 
On the other hand, if two partners agreed that one would earn ownership by working for free or less than market rate, then that can equate to money. Or if one contributes existing intellectual property such as written material or software code, that can equate to money too. But that should be spelled out and agreed upon before you start. 
 
And I personally don’t believe having had the idea, or not, matters. Ideas have no value. Work has value. Creative work and patents have value. Content has value. And money has value. Ideas don’t. 
 
To me this is yet another example of why I’ve said, and written, over and over again, get it in writing. Not necessarily all legalese like a contract, but at least the basic points of agreements, with signatures. Here‘s what one lawyer (and I’m not a lawyer, so don’t think I’m giving you legal advice here) says about that:
 
It goes without saying: the best way to deal with a botched verbal contract is to avoid the whole mess in the first place. Get it in writing. People remember things differently. People don’t remember. People lie.
 
Get it in writing. And then stick to it. 
 
This article was originally published by Tim Berry

Filed Under: Legal Tagged With: Equity, Legal Issues, Partnerships, Planning, Starting a Business, Tim Berry

Tim Berry

Tim Berry

Tim Berry is co-founder of Have Presence, founder and Chairman of Palo Alto Software, founder of bplans.com, and a co-founder of Borland International. He is author of books and software including LivePlan and Business Plan Pro, The Plan-As-You-Go Business Plan, and Lean Business Planning, published by Motivational Press in 2015. He has a Stanford MBA degree and degrees with honors from the University of Oregon and the University of Notre Dame. He taught starting a business at the University of Oregon for 11 years.

Related Posts

  • 5 Issues in a Slip-and-Fall Case Where You Need an Attorney
  • Moving Your Business: 5 Things to Examine
  • When and Why Do You Need Legal Transcription?

Primary Sidebar

Random

Attracting Investors for Your Start Up Business

Jan 20, 2014 By Bill Bradley

13 Content Distribution and Promotion Channels and Their Perceived Value

Jan 14, 2014 By Chad Pollitt

When Less is More!

Nov 2, 2016 By Dave Brock

10 Strategies That Will Fail At Attracting Investors

May 21, 2020 By Marty Zwilling

A Plan Based on “Bluebirds” Is Not a Plan

Jun 3, 2014 By Dave Brock

Footer

About Us

Small Biz Club is the premier destination for small business owners and entrepreneurs. To succeed in business, you have to constantly learn about new things, evaluate what you’re doing, and look for ways to improve—that’s what we’re here to help you do.

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Copyright © 2023 by Tarkenton Institute, Inc. All Rights Reserved | Terms | Privacy